I never had an Amiga computer, nor did my friends, sadly, so I didn't have the chance to experience playing games on it. I went from the Commodore 64 to a PC. I remember, however, how the old magazines always had screens for the C64 and Amiga versions of games next to each other, and the Amiga were always the best looking ones. :)

Here's a list of what we have gotten since late 2015, based on the wishlists here (before the bump) :)

X-Com games
Vampires the Masquerade Bloodlines
Crysis 1 + Warhead
Strife
System Shock
Requiem: Avenging Angel
Armed and Dangerous
Quake III
Army Men 1 and 2
Men of Valor
Titan Quest
Torchlight II
GUN
Freddy Pharkas: Frontier Pharmacist
Impossible Creatures
Prison Architect
TRON 2.0
Dragon Age: Origins
Risen 3
Homeworld
Emperor: Rise of the Middle Kingdom
Railroad Tycoon 3
X series
Imperium Galactica 2
Day of the Tentacle
Dark Sun: Shattered Lands
Star Wars Battlefront 1
Simcity 3000
SWAT 4
Caeser IV
Freedom Force

My smartass list, a work in progress:

- Hatred
- Battlecruiser 3000 AD (a different kind of "Hatred")
- Custer's Revenge
- Half Life
- Star Citizen

Elder Scrolls Oblivion + DLC
Caves of Qud
Age of Empires
Wizardy 1- 5
The Neverhood
Red Orchestra 1 + 2
Dark Souls
Marathon
Oregon Trail
Resident Evil

Mini Ninjas
Scarface - The World Is Yours
One Finger Death Punch
Shivers
Hunter Hunted
Blade Runner
GTA series
Hitman Blood Money
Duke Nukem series
Fallout New Vegas
The Neverhood
Soldier Of Fortune
Grimoire
Kane & Lynch series

That's 10, right?

1. The Guild 3
2. The Sims 2
3. Zoo Tycoon 2
4. Zoo Tycoon 1
5. The Sims 1
6. Anno 2070
7. Sid Meier's Civilization V
8. The Sims 4
9. Planet Coaster
10. Cities Skylines

1. Discworld 1 +2 + Noir
2. No one lives forever 1 + 2 + Contract Jack
3. Wizardy 1 - 5
4. Call of Cthulhu, Dark corners of the Earth
5. Crusader kings 2 + all DLC
6. The whole Command and Conquer series
7. Magic candle 1 + 2 + 3
8. Amberstar + Ambermoon
9. MacVentures
10. Ripper

Still to be released here.

1 - Discworld Noir
2 - Bladerunner
3 - Heretic/ Hexen games
4 - C&C series
5 - Cinemaware collection
6 - Fallout 3
7 - Diablo series
8 - Rest of the Monkey Island games
9 - Max Payne series
10 - Anything and everything Amiga!

Not exaclty a top 10, but a list of game I've made a search on GOG.com before any purchase.

1 Dragon Age: Origins
2 Metal Gear Solid
3 WarCraft III + Frozen Throne (I already own them, but they don't work on win 10)
4 Drakensang Anthology
5 Diablo I and Diablo II +expansions
6 Metal fatigue
7 Blood and Magic
8 Vampire the Masquerade Bloodlines
9 Warcraft II
10 Warlords battlecry III

And, out of the 10, but not for this less desired, the first Call to power.
There is the n°2, but the first is not present and that is sad for me, because I have played it for so long that I have damaged the play disk... Sigh!

Are already on GOG.

I don't know about top 10 but recently there are two games that I have been wanting to play.

Myth: The Fallen Lords
Myth: Soulblighter

I suppose I wouldn't mind playing the third one again, although it wasn't as good as the others.

I actually own the game disk for all three but my computer doesn't have an optical drive.

My top ten list! Mostly Star Trek games with a few others sprinkled in.

1. Star Trek Klingon Academy
2. Star Trek Starfleet Command 3
3. Star Trek Honor Guard
4. Mechwarrior series
6. Diablo 1 and 2
7. Star Trek Elite Force 1 and 2
8. Freelancer
9. Star Trek Armada 1 & 2
10. Star Trek A Final Unity

Many greats from the 80s & 90s:

1. Commander Keen: Aliens Ate My Babysitter (or any episode from the series for that matter)
2. Jazz Jackrabbit 1 (everything from the old Epic Megagames seems to be MIA)
3. Jazz Jackrabbit 2 ( ^see above)
4. Thexder (GameArts/GungHo is probably holding out.. who knows)
5. Silpheed ( ^see above)
6. Arcticfox
7. LHX Attack Chopper
8. Test Drive (probably unlikely due to licensing issues?)
9. Skate or Die
10. Caveman Ugh-lympics

I actually only have one request. The Carnivores series:

Carnivores

Carnivores 2

Ice Age

I have all three versions but they don't work very well on XP.