It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
johnnygoging: I didn't mind it. Also, I don't feel that they changed around the character of the Emperor whenever it was convenient. They almost immediately set her up as less evil than Lorca, maybe less evil than the norm for the darkling universe.
I saw absolutely nothing of the sort. She's totally evil until in this episode where it's suddenly like we're supposed to treat her as some noble ruler betrayed by an evil villain. If anything it would have made much more sense for Burnham to throw her lot in with Lorca. All she knows is that Georgiou fucking eats people and slaughtered without a glance the entire rebelion Burnham was trying to protect, and Lorca is the guy who's trying to overthrow her.

avatar
johnnygoging: you got Michelle Yeoh all up in the business then you're gonna get Kung Fu and if you don't like I will personally Single Whip some sense into you.
Yeah, given her record I should be grateful it wasn't even worse :P I absolutely hate those asian martial arts movies. Haaaaate.

avatar
johnnygoging: everyone was surprised that lorca was darkling. they just didn't spend a lot of time dwelling on it. they're starfleet, dammit! I don't know when these were filmed and how long the Trek community has known about Lorca but if they knew that the Trek community knew, they wouldn't have really driven the reveal hard after that.
I really doubt they make those episodes within weeks of release :P

avatar
johnnygoging: do you mean events leading to TOS?
Yes.

avatar
johnnygoging: dude, if the plan was for this universe (the "main" one in this show), to be the canon universe, it's gone now. we are in another universe. I have no doubts that we are seeing a non-darkling alternate universe to the old shows.
That's my "headcanon" too, but I very much doubt that's the intention behind the show.

avatar
johnnygoging: the only thing that's kind of lame is that Lorca's a little shpoo!
What in the hell does that mean?

avatar
Vitek: Hmpf, until the very last part I even felt like the show is setup better than it was before. That means with Lorca out and Saru as captain who actually possibly tries to utilize his crew properly but then it went back downhill (from the small hill it was on).
Yeah, I actually did like Saru as captain and the crew working together in a semi-proper Star Trek fassion. Hey, the no-name bridge people actually have names!

avatar
PixelBoy: Flash grenade!!!

Damn that was stupid.
I liked more the scene at the end where Georgiou is standing out in the open and dozens of soldiers are just rushing in and dying as she mows them down and no one can hit here like in a game with hilariously bad AI. Man, those Terran guys have worse aim than the Stormtroopers.
Post edited January 30, 2018 by Breja
avatar
Breja: I saw absolutely nothing of the sort. She's totally evil until in this episode where it's suddenly like we're supposed to treat her as some noble ruler betrayed by an evil villain. If anything it would have made much more sense for Burnham to throw her lot in with Lorca. All she knows is that Georgiou fucking eats people and slaughtered without a glance the entire rebelion Burnham was trying to protect, and Lorca is the guy who's trying to overthrow her.
Hmm I guess you do have a point. We've only had this Emperor for a couple of episodes so we're still getting to know her. So as far as I was concerned, we're still seeing what kind of character she has. When you condense it a bit and look at it over the span of the last few episodes, I guess it does look like a bit of an arbitrary turn. They were introducing her as a major villain though so I think it's understandable if they tried to do with flare.

avatar
johnnygoging: the only thing that's kind of lame is that Lorca's a little shpoo!
avatar
Breja: What in the hell does that mean?
It's a TF2 reference. When Lorca got death-by-giant-shiny-spaceball I immediately thought that he's gonna go into the mycelium network and we won't have seen the last of him. Then at the end of the show a little green Spore breaks off from the rest and goes ominously into Tilly. I doubt it's Hugh.

avatar
Vitek: Hmpf, until the very last part I even felt like the show is setup better than it was before. That means with Lorca out and Saru as captain who actually possibly tries to utilize his crew properly but then it went back downhill (from the small hill it was on).
avatar
Breja: Yeah, I actually did like Saru as captain and the crew working together in a semi-proper Star Trek fassion. Hey, the no-name bridge people actually have names!
Agreed. I generally have really not liked the Saru character, but he's been a surprisingly good Captain.
avatar
Breja: Why is the show acting like Lorca is "a bad guy" and the Empress is one of the "good guys"?
You perfectly know why, Breja. I've (and I think other people in this thread) told you many times. You are just in denial.
avatar
johnnygoging: It's a TF2 reference. When Lorca got death-by-giant-shiny-spaceball I immediately thought that he's gonna go into the mycelium network and we won't have seen the last of him. Then at the end of the show a little green Spore breaks off from the rest and goes ominously into Tilly. I doubt it's Hugh.
Yeah, that was my first thought when he was falling down the drive. "OMG? He is not gone, he's going to merge with the spores."
Then the stray green spore came and I died inside a little.


Speaking of spores, it is kind of funny how similar the effect of them flying around is to The Expanse protomolecule airborne effect.
avatar
johnnygoging: It's a TF2 reference. When Lorca got death-by-giant-shiny-spaceball I immediately thought that he's gonna go into the mycelium network and we won't have seen the last of him. Then at the end of the show a little green Spore breaks off from the rest and goes ominously into Tilly. I doubt it's Hugh.
avatar
Vitek: Yeah, that was my first thought when he was falling down the drive. "OMG? He is not gone, he's going to merge with the spores."
My first thought was that it's funny how they are still using that "screaming in pain even after body has been disintegrated", which dates back to the first movies in Star Trek context.
avatar
PixelBoy: My first thought was that it's funny how they are still using that "screaming in pain even after body has been disintegrated", which dates back to the first movies in Star Trek context.
It's because the scream was so horrible it resonates in our ears even after its author perishes. ;-)
avatar
johnnygoging: When Lorca got death-by-giant-shiny-spaceball I immediately thought that he's gonna go into the mycelium network and we won't have seen the last of him. Then at the end of the show a little green Spore breaks off from the rest and goes ominously into Tilly. I doubt it's Hugh.
Oh sweet tribbles, I didn't even think of that. I seriously thought they were just playing with the pretty lights. But I can see that, it's exactly the kind of stupid shit they'd pull on this show. I guess by the end of the season we'll be lucky if there'll be anyone except Burnham who won't turn out to be evil one way or another :P
avatar
PixelBoy: My first thought was that it's funny how they are still using that "screaming in pain even after body has been disintegrated", which dates back to the first movies in Star Trek context.
avatar
Vitek: It's because the scream was so horrible it resonates in our ears even after its author perishes. ;-)
KHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANN !!!!

MR. TAMBOURINE MAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANN !!!!!
avatar
Breja: Fuck me this is stupid.
Well, I have to agree with you this time. I really liked this series until last episode that, basically, killed it. It was awful!!!

avatar
Breja: Why is the show acting like Lorca is "a bad guy" and the Empress is one of the "good guys"? She's just as evil if not more! She's basically Hitler if he also ate people!
Actually, in orevious episode empress said that Mirror Lorca and Burnham tried to "poison" Empire with some kind of liberalism and weakness. And now everything completely changed!!! Empress is good and Lorca is evil! How and when this happened?! Total crap!!!

avatar
Breja: And can we please stop with this ridiculous, over the top kung-fu nonsense? This is (supposedly) Star Trek, not Arrow. It's just like the new X-Files where Mulder and Scully are suddenly Jason Bourne level badasses. Is this now a requirement for every modern tv show?
This king-fu looked really idiotic! They went full SJW this time...

Also, Burnham is really shitty character now. Lorca didn't wanted to kill her in fight, asked her to stop. And what in the end?! He is a bad guy??? After he agreed to let Discovery go? Right now I ready to agree - they killed Star Trek.

avatar
Breja: I love how almost no one is at all surprised about Lorca being Terran and evil.
That was a nice twist.

avatar
Breja: And now we learn that the Federation was decimated by the Klingons, almost obliterated. And yet just a few years later there is no trace of this cataclismic war. None.
Yes, that was very stupid too...

avatar
Breja: The only good thing about this episode was the lack of Klingons. I guess we all just forgot about Tyler/Voq, and I'm fine with that.
Voq was interesting and they killed him. Almost all interesting characters are dead now, so watching Discovery is pointless for me...

Predicting: they will save Federation in 1 or 2 episodes. :)
I will miss Lorca (if he doesn't appear again), but at least we will have more Michelle Yeoh. :) The way I see it, Michael was presented with two evils so he chose the lesser one (that is, the one that isn't sickly obsessed with her and will allow her to return to her universe). Michael is an emotional mess (possibly because of her Vulcan upbringing) so she probably still feels guilty about betraying her Georgiou. Anyway, I'm not going to complain about more Georgiou, even if she is from the Mirror Universe.

I liked the cliffhanger in the end. I think it's too soon to panic about continuity issues. That very same scene established that the mycellium network allows to time travel, so... This has "Year of Hell" written all over it. Not particularly original, but at least we get to see the Federation conquered by the Klingons for a couple of episodes.

The greatest surprise of the episode was how good Saru works as a captain. Finally they gave the character enough to work with. He would be a fantastic captain for season 2.
Post edited February 01, 2018 by Caesar.
avatar
Caesar.: I will miss Lorca (if he doesn't appear again), but at least we will have more Michelle Yeoh. :) The way I see it, Michael was presented with two evils so he chose the lesser one (that is, the one that isn't sickly obsessed with her and will allow her to return to her universe). Michael is an emotional mess (possibly because of her Vulcan upbringing) so she probably still feels guilty about betraying her Georgiou. Anyway, I'm not going to complain about more Georgiou, even if she is from the Mirror Universe.

I liked the cliffhanger in the end. I think it's too soon to panic about continuity issues. That very same scene established that the mycellium network allows to time travel, so... This has "Year of Hell" written all over it. Not particularly original, but at least we get to see the Federation conquered by the Klingons for a couple of episodes.

The greatest surprise of the episode was how good Saru works as a captain. Finally they gave the character enough to work with. He would be a fantastic captain for season 2.
Saru was fantastic! Right you are
avatar
Caesar.: I think it's too soon to panic about continuity issues.
It's more like too late to panic acout continuity issues. Terran Empire was never racist in Trek - many aliens served on the ships side by side with humans. It's all forgotten now.
avatar
Caesar.: I think it's too soon to panic about continuity issues.
avatar
LootHunter: It's more like too late to panic acout continuity issues. Terran Empire was never racist in Trek - many aliens served on the ships side by side with humans. It's all forgotten now.
Usually I can't tell because I have seen next to nothing of TOS, but I see an easy explanation there. The shows take place in different time periods, and in Enterprise the Empire was already racist (T'Pol is treated as an inferior to humans). So the Terran Empire started racist (Enterprise), during the next 100 years became superracist (Discovery), and by the time TOS takes place someone (Lorca's people or whoever becomes Emperor) changes that.
avatar
Caesar.: Enterprise the Empire was already racist (T'Pol is treated as an inferior to humans).
But that's the thing! It wasn't!
T'Pol was assistant on the bridge. And Archer made her his first mate (Number one). Could ever slave become first mate? Moreover, after he tells her about vulcans, that they are slaves now instead of humans. She answers "So that's your attitude towards vulcans?", implying that Archer's opinion is not generally shared by other Terrans.

And anyway, Dr. Phlox is also an officer on the Enterprise - so again even if vulcans were treated as servants (by some terrans at least), denobulans weren't. This is completely incompatible with "Terran Empire rejects any change and outside culture" told in Discovery.

Also, we talk mere a decade between Discovery and TOS. Considering that in US after abolishing slavery there were about hunderd years of segregation and KKK, it's even more hard to believe that Empire went from "no aliens among the crew" to vulcans being respected crewmembers in such a short time.
Post edited February 01, 2018 by LootHunter
avatar
Caesar.: Enterprise the Empire was already racist (T'Pol is treated as an inferior to humans).
avatar
LootHunter: But that's the thing! It wasn't!
T'Pol was assistant on the bridge. And Archer made her his first mate (Number one). Could ever slave become first mate? Moreover, after he tells her about vulcans, that they are slaves now instead of humans. She answers "So that's your attitude towards vulcans?", implying that Archer's opinion is not generally shared by other Terrans.

And anyway, Dr. Phlox is also an officer on the Enterprise - so again even if vulcans were treated as servants (by some terrans at least), denobulans weren't. This is completely incompatible with "Terran Empire rejects any change and outside culture" told in Discovery.
My impression was that Vulcans were barely tolerated and treated inequally. Weren't they brutally conquered (as any non-human species)? As for Phlox, he is the only Denobulan we see. Maybe he's so good at his job they don't mind. Maybe Denobulans are allies who provide biological weapons to the Terrans. It's a work of fiction, there are infinite explanations.

Anyway, even if I don't remember correctly the Enterprise episodes, which could very well be, it's not that big of a deal. So much can change in 100 years. Even a decade is enough time to completely change the world.