I did some quick searching, FOX Games was bought by Vivendi Games, who merged with Activision. So who knows owns the game rights :(

But at least people can have the chance to legally buy them again as digital downloads, and have them be reasonably compatible with new systems. There will always be those who go back to the games on their childhood and realize they're crappy and hard compared to today's games, but naturally that's not GOG's fault. I'm grateful that GOG does this.

couldn't agree more. I can understand C&C and Red Alert titles not being there due to their availability on the market, but Myth series are some of the best strategy games ever made. Same goes for Warhammer: Shadow of the Horned Rat and Warhammer: Dark Omen

I think GOG and many of us agree that signing LucasArts - however likely or unlikely that will happen this year, next year, etc. - is top priority.

Damm it, Z deserves to be in top 10 RTS.

I appreciate the list but I'm kind of confused as to why Action, Platformer and Puzzle are all one group. The ironic thing in that is that action and puzzle are widely considered the opposite ends of the platformer spectrum.

And then to me, racing and sports have NOTHING to do with fighting games.

fair question :) for several reasons... firstly, having a separate list for each genre would make my job much more difficult as there are some genres which don't have much games with many requests. so I bundled some genres.

I do see a relation between action and platformer or sports and fighting or racing and sports. On the other hand, you are right about puzzle. But that was just for the purpose of putting lemmings in one of the categories :)

Yep.I actually liked that game over AOE as well :)

I edited the list with American McGee's Alice and Starcraft. Please let me know if I skipped any other games.

Sure people might disagree with me. Myth is best if you can be patient and get something out of the story/setting and like just being in the simple ambiance (I'd say the same thing about Homeworld & Myst). This might alienate the faster-paced Action, FPS, or RTS gamers. I think most people would appreciate how unique it is, though, if they played it.

See, here's the issue with your original post on the subject. You phrased your opinion as fact. Which turns your whole argument into a fallacy.

Action/Platformer/Puzzle
Jazz Jackrabbit now has more votes than Syndicate Wars.
The Elder Scrolls Adventures: Redguard entered the list, pushing Jazz Jackrabbit 2 out.

Adventure
Maniac Mansion: Day of the Tentacle now has more votes than Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis.

RPG
Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines now has more votes than The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall.
Wasteland now has more votes than Baldur's Gate: Enhanced Edition.

RTS/Turn Based Strategy
Homeworld: Catacylsm and Age of Mythology now have more votes than Dune II.

Shooter
Aliens vs Predator 2 now has more votes than Jedi Knight - Dark Forces II.
Aliens vs Predator entered the list, pushing Mechwarrior 2: Mercenaries out.

Space and Flight Sim/Shooter and other Sim
SimCity 3000 entered the list, pushing Star Wars: X-Wing vs Tie Fighter: Balance of Power Campaigns out.

added new category: Missing stuff, Superior Versions...

expanded the above category to top 10

Syndicate Wars is now removed and Jazz Jackrabbit 2 entered the list.