It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
bler144: There are plenty of other reasons to lynch Leonard whether or not he's telling the truth about role/action. But I'd still really prefer yogs post his theory before we hammer rather than after. Especially since "after" he could easily fake just by conveniently being offline.

Mostly I'm debating whether to go ahead and vote Leonard and give yogs another day, vs. not. I don't know that he needs to full claim, but...something other than "trust me" would be nice, since, y'know, I've learned from experience not to trust him.
You think I could fake being offline? lmao I'm like a junkie slamming Mafia-flavored smack into my veins every day.

So my reveal is all typed up. Four pages worth.

Here's the problem, though, bler. I've had a lot of time to put it together. It's perfectly logical, highly detailed, and well annotated. After reading it, you'll know exactly what I've been doing and why every step of the way. The only reasonable conclusion is that I really am Town and have been working steadily, to the best of my abilities, to correctly lynch the bad guys every day. And thus far have been largely successful.

How do you suppose you'll respond to something like that?
avatar
Bookwyrm627: I don't know how many jailers are in the setup. I'm asking whether there is any reason to conclude 3 potential RBs/jailers can't be the case. As above, is there any evidence beyond "seems weird to have that many"?

Maybe I'm just acclimated to high numbers of role block type abilities, but why does 2 seem all that high? Under other circumstances, I might agree that 3 would be stretching credibility, but my credibility checker overloaded while processing Adalia's flip.

avatar
yogsloth: Shall we stare at each other in contemplative silence?
avatar
Bookwyrm627: I could go for some LAY, myself. ;)
I spent a while on D2 contemplating 3 jailers/blockers, and I agree that we can't rule out multiple jailers having targeted either adalia (generally perceived as questionable) or Hijack (known to be vulnerable) since either could be a viable play for town or scum while still easy to sell as "townie."

I do think it worth noting, however, that while there were 3 claimed blockers/jailers last game, at least one of them was lying (Hijack). I don't remember who the other two were or if they were real.

So if your question is, is it likely? Yes, I see that. Is it plausible? Eh...

On the last point - lol

Yogs statement was a bit ironic considering he seems to have the most to share and is choosing not to do so for "the reasons."
avatar
yogsloth: Shall we stare at each other in contemplative silence?
Well you could share what you know. Considering the only difference between sharing it now, and after the lynch is that we get to talk about it before the lynch, generally a towny thing, you know?
avatar
yogsloth: Here's the problem, though, bler. I've had a lot of time to put it together. It's perfectly logical, highly detailed, and well annotated. After reading it, you'll know exactly what I've been doing and why every step of the way. The only reasonable conclusion is that I really am Town and have been working steadily, to the best of my abilities, to correctly lynch the bad guys every day. And thus far have been largely successful.

How do you suppose you'll respond to something like that?
Had to run to a mtg with the boss and didn't refresh.

Depends on what you have to say and how the pieces fit - mostly how well you can account for what you knew (or guessed) and how.

The real upside to getting it now is that it gives you less wiggle room to revise your story later, whether or not it changes anything about today's vote.
avatar
bler144: Depends on what you have to say and how the pieces fit - mostly how well you can account for what you knew (or guessed) and how.

The real upside to getting it now is that it gives you less wiggle room to revise your story later, whether or not it changes anything about today's vote.
[trumpets] The truth needs no wiggle room!

Listen - I'll all about lynching Leonard today, for all the reasons you and me and most people can see about how the Day 1 lynch went down and the following claimed actions and behaviors. You know it, I know it, I'm on the record for it.

I have a good reason for not wanting to lay all my cards down yet. Trust me because reasons friendly happy OHyogsotownie OHOHyogsotownie.

Leonard has three votes. You're waiting to pull the trigger, with or without my amazing mind control powers to force you to do so. So is cristi. I suspect so are others. Maybe trent might even flop back on at the end, who knows?

Take the chance. You know you want to. Search your feelings, bluke.
avatar
yogsloth: Trust me because...
I followed/agreed with most of it, but you lost me on that part.
avatar
bler144: ...mtg...
So when I read that I thought of this. Is that a sign of too much gaming?
avatar
bler144: ...mtg...
avatar
Leonard03: So when I read that I thought of this. Is that a sign of too much gaming?
No comment.
avatar
bler144: ...mtg...
avatar
Leonard03: So when I read that I thought of this. Is that a sign of too much gaming?
If you still have the money to pay the bills, then no.
avatar
Ixamyakxim: If I were to ask yog to give anything today, I think it would have to do with why he feels better about the P1na flip.
Because I don't think the bad guys were organized yet.

And I think that's about all out of me for a while.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: If you still have the money to pay the bills, then no.
I actually don't have any, just played it a couple times. I'm really tempted by the starter decks though, just scared of what might happen next...
Which actually makes me think, you call yourself "Master of Magic". Maybe, this magic?
avatar
Ixamyakxim: If I were to ask yog to give anything today, I think it would have to do with why he feels better about the P1na flip.
avatar
yogsloth: Because I don't think the bad guys were organized yet.

And I think that's about all out of me for a while.
How does that even make sense? Are you proposing a power that requires a coordinated group action? What am I missing?

Once again, your answer is a non-answer. Starting to lean towards voting you.
avatar
Leonard03: I actually don't have any, just played it a couple times. I'm really tempted by the starter decks though, just scared of what might happen next...
Which actually makes me think, you call yourself "Master of Magic". Maybe, this magic?
*sonorous tones*
This magic is mighty indeed (and power creeping with every new expansion, but that's beside the point), but no. I am a of a far mightier [url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r1XdBgwoIqY]magic.
avatar
yogsloth: Shall we stare at each other in contemplative silence?
Sounds fun.

As for me, I wanted to lynch Leonard03 Yesterday, and nothing has changed. I gave my reasons then, and they remain valid Today. The whole situation with Leonard03's claim jailing, and flubbucket's denial that he got a PM to that effect, is interesting, but moot.

As for the folks turning on yogsloth... I have no idea if he has some nefarious agenda, but he does seem to be seeing things similarly to the way I am. So, count me out of any yogsloth wagon, unless something crazy happens to change my mind.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: *sonorous tones*
This magic is mighty indeed (and power creeping with every new expansion, but that's beside the point), but no. I am a of a far mightier [url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r1XdBgwoIqY]magic.
Oooh. I see. That's where your avatar is from then too?