It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Does Gog only handle games - that have been officially patched to work w/o a disc, never needed to have the disc in, or can be mounted in DOSBox?
Then, some games like (uh perhaps) Nox (don't remember how that was with the disc)... would never be seen here?
Cause the Gog team won't use or allowed to use externally developed no-cd cracks, right?
And for most parts I guess the original developers won't have that much interests in making a nocd patch for a game that is, well, very old.
Post edited December 24, 2009 by Hipshot
GOG would mostly be working with the source code. Which wouldn't include any form of security measure, including disc checks. They do a lot of the programming work themselves to get titles working on modern versions of Windows, so removing copy protection (where necessary and with consent) wouldn't be any more a problem for them than it is for the pirates.
I don't think there's any official patch to make Heroes 3 or Ground Control not require the disc (to take two examples), instead GOG received a version where the CD check has not been added (thus it doesn't have to be removed).
Though there's at least one game (I forget which one) where it asks for a CD if you start with one exe file but not through the other (GOG's start menu shortcuts of course point to the one not looking for the disc).
avatar
Navagon: GOG would mostly be working with the source code. Which wouldn't include any form of security measure, including disc checks. They do a lot of the programming work themselves to get titles working on modern versions of Windows, so removing copy protection (where necessary and with consent) wouldn't be any more a problem for them than it is for the pirates.

Except we can pretty much count on gog games not having nasty little payloads inside, like with pirate-versions ;)
avatar
Hipshot: Does Gog only handle games - that have been officially patched to work w/o a disc, never needed to have the disc in, or can be mounted in DOSBox?
Then, some games like (uh perhaps) Nox (don't remember how that was with the disc)... would never be seen here?
Cause the Gog team won't use or allowed to use externally developed no-cd cracks, right?
And for most parts I guess the original developers won't have that much interests in making a nocd patch for a game that is, well, very old.

By the way, older GOG games come bundled with DOSBox too. You don't have to mount anything, it just works.
avatar
Lone3wolf: Except we can pretty much count on gog games not having nasty little payloads inside, like with pirate-versions ;)

I wasn't advocating piracy. The OP brought it up, so I addressed it in that manner.
Although it's worth pointing out that 'dirty' pirated copies are often unofficially released by the publisher. Cracking groups have their own little sense of pride and releasing malware would kill their much valued reputation.
avatar
Lone3wolf: Except we can pretty much count on gog games not having nasty little payloads inside, like with pirate-versions ;)
avatar
Navagon: I wasn't advocating piracy. The OP brought it up, so I addressed it in that manner.
Although it's worth pointing out that 'dirty' pirated copies are often unofficially released by the publisher. Cracking groups have their own little sense of pride and releasing malware would kill their much valued reputation.

Yeah, I'm not condoning, or saying anyone here is....just highlighting one of the benefits of supporting gog, and developers by buying the games here, rather than "acquiring" them elsewhere :P
Plus the support for getting even very old games working;
Plus the ever-expanding catalogue;
Plus the Community;
Plus the lack of (often debilitating) *ANY* DRM;
Plus the cheap prices; and by extension, the insane promos and sales! (cheap as they are, my bank account is hating it :P );
Plus the ability to re-download at will....
Gog for World President!!
avatar
Hipshot: Does Gog only handle games - that have been officially patched to work w/o a disc, never needed to have the disc in, or can be mounted in DOSBox?
Then, some games like (uh perhaps) Nox (don't remember how that was with the disc)... would never be seen here?
Cause the Gog team won't use or allowed to use externally developed no-cd cracks, right?
And for most parts I guess the original developers won't have that much interests in making a nocd patch for a game that is, well, very old.

GOG creates the nocd functionality. They have programmers that make a new .exe and a new installation for each game.
avatar
Hipshot: Does Gog only handle games - that have been officially patched to work w/o a disc, never needed to have the disc in, or can be mounted in DOSBox?
Then, some games like (uh perhaps) Nox (don't remember how that was with the disc)... would never be seen here?
Cause the Gog team won't use or allowed to use externally developed no-cd cracks, right?
And for most parts I guess the original developers won't have that much interests in making a nocd patch for a game that is, well, very old.
avatar
captfitz: GOG creates the nocd functionality. They have programmers that make a new .exe and a new installation for each game.

Not necessarily true. Some games require more "love" than others before GOG sells them, but GOG does not create a brand new executable for every single game they sell (they do create custom installers for all the games though). Sometimes all they do is create a custom config for DOSBox and provide the game as it originally was, other times they have created a modified launcher that uses the same original .exe, still other times publishers/devs have provided them with executables that have already had the DRM removed. Basically, it is different for every game and totally depends on what is required for that particular game to run DRM free.
avatar
Lone3wolf: Gog for World President!!

That's not a title I'd wish on my worst enemy, to be honest. =p
avatar
captfitz: GOG creates the nocd functionality. They have programmers that make a new .exe and a new installation for each game.
avatar
cogadh: Not necessarily true. Some games require more "love" than others before GOG sells them, but GOG does not create a brand new executable for every single game they sell (they do create custom installers for all the games though). Sometimes all they do is create a custom config for DOSBox and provide the game as it originally was, other times they have created a modified launcher that uses the same original .exe, still other times publishers/devs have provided them with executables that have already had the DRM removed. Basically, it is different for every game and totally depends on what is required for that particular game to run DRM free.

i know, i just didn't want to go into more detail than 'they make it work themselves.' no one had properly addressed that fact when i posted.