I bought a star to test it out and got:

Armikrog

I hadn't heard of it before but I must say the reviews are not filling me with confidence. I shall try it out though.

Dropped $15 to see what I'd come up with.

Death to Spies: Moment of Truth
Darkstar One
BIT.TRIP Presents Runner 2
Earthlock: Festival of Magic
The Vanishing of Ethan Carter

So for me the score is

1 I'd never play (Bit.Trip)
3 I might have tried out if they were super cheap
1 I was actually considering getting (Ethan Carter)

Not too bad a haul. Will probably loot box more when I get paid next week.

Port Royal 2
UFO: Aftermath
Sherlock Holmes: Secret of Silver Earring
Fantasy Wars
Kings Bounty: Warrior of the North
Warrior Kings:Battles
Ghost Master
Codename Panzers
Darwinia


Nothing that screams out "play me!"

Kids might like Ghost master and Darwinia did peak my interest many years back.

Suppose I got luckly last time with OwlBoy

Took 4 more stars and got:

Kim
Beat Cop
Barony: Cursed Edition
Holy Potatoes! We're in Space?!

Not bad at all considering i didn't own anything but the Beat Cop elsewhere.

Edit: Another one bites the dust

Darksiders Warmastered Edition

Just to try it out I bought one star, I got the game:

Gun

GOG is selling it for $10 and its $20 on Steam
seems to have very positive reviews
people said its like an older Red Dead Redemption
Looks like something I might enjoy playing I'll give it a go

I bought one.

Hacknet

On sale for $3.29, and doesn't come with any of the DLC.

Menh.

Bit.Trip beat
Bit.Trip Flux
Combat mission: beyond overlord
Crime Cities
Death to Spies: Moment of Truth
Double Dragon Trilogy
Dreamfall Chapters: The Final Cut
Gun
Holy Potatoes! A weapon shop?!
Holy Potatoes! We're in Space?!
Hybrid Wars
I Have no MOuth And I must scream
King's Bounty: Crossworlds GOTY
Layers of Fear
LEgo Batman 2 DC Super Heroes
Noctropolis
ON Rusty Trails
OVerclocked: A History of Violence
Pajama Sam Vol. 2
Perimeter
Sherlock Holmes Versus Jack the Ripper
Sherlock Holmes: Nemesis - Remastered
Stronghold Crusader 2
Sunless Sea
The Swindle
Transistor
UnderRail
Warrior Kings: Battles




Ok that's enough for now

third star

got On Rusty Trails, I don't even know what that game is lol :D

Legend of Kay: Anniversary
Dreamfall Chapters: The Final Cut
I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream
Ys: The Oath in Felghana
Masquerada: Songs and Shadows

I don't like to play lottery, but usually get one game this way every time a chance occurs. Got Patrician III. I guess, it's alright. Never played it, since it seemed too serious, but now I have no chance, but to try it.

I had to run my copy of Patrician III through the compatibilty check. The colors come of the menu come out inverted otherwise.

GUN
Stories: Path of Destinies
Homeworld: Emergence
Dreamfall Chapters: The Final Cut
Scanner Sombre
Perimiter
Tahira: Echoes of the Astral Empire
Space Rangers HD: A War Apart
Delta Force Xtreme
Star Wolves
Space Rogue Classic
Bit.Trip Flux
Jack Keane
Transistor

Decent haul overall I think. Still, asked for a refund for 3 I'm never going to play (Scanner Sombre for sure) and one that I own already on Steam. Will just roll the dice and try stars again xD
Will update if I get new ones ^_^


Update:
Requiem: Avenging Angel
Warrior Kings
Legend of Kay: Anniversary
Bit.Trip Fate

Still got stuck with a bit.trip game, but honestly for the $3 mark I think the loot is worth it if you're looking to branch out or try something different. And heck, you may even get something nice.

Second star. Bit Trip Flux.

I tried my luck and got "Skyshine's BEDLAM Redux!". It certainly looks interesting.

2 more stars after refunds and I got

Sunless Sea (over the moon to get this one)
Jagged Alliance: Deadly Games (refund requested as I won't play it)

Not bad really, even though I'm refunding ja:DG I've been happy with most of my stars, much more than those pinatas...
It's actually a really cool game and I hate most hacking games. But if it's not your thing I hope you asked for a refund. Then you could try again for another
Are you sure that's enough? Ha ha.... A good mix you have there, some very nice games ;)