It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #78 - Regular Japanese Classroom(865 posts)(865 posts)
(865 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
33
34
35
36
37
50
58
This is my favourite topic
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
supplementscene: What result did you get?
Sidenote : Now I do not think that Scene and Joe would both be scum.

avatar
Telika: Not certain I should allow Joe to answer that. On one hand it would be a nice verification system, on the other hand it would only verify if Joe is a tracker, which is independent from alignment.
avatar
Atlo: Seriously?!
Uh? Yes, seriously, why ?

There are town trackers and there a mafia trackers.
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
supplementscene: Lift voted for Joe for this reason but pretended Catte offered insight, which is a LIE.
It sounds to me that you're accusing Liftraisal of lying but voting for the person you're accusing him of lying about.
Posted November 06, 2022
oh hi page 11

i guess scum can have a tracker but it's not usual - and it's not the case here
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
supplementscene: Lift voted for Joe for this reason but pretended Catte offered insight, which is a LIE.
avatar
my name is anime catte: It sounds to me that you're accusing Liftraisal of lying but voting for the person you're accusing him of lying about.
Lift's wagon isn't going anywhere, isn't viable and we're less than 2 hours to lynch. Plus you voted for me. If you want to switch your vote to Lift, I'll move mine back. Otherwise it's on your wagon
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
supplementscene: I call Lift, Catte and Booktooth as my provisional all 3 scum players
So how do you interpret Atlo's warning about Catte (post 457) ?
Posted November 06, 2022
@Scene: sure. A protective role who announces whom they are going to protect. If you really are what you say you are that would be a bad idea, even by your standard.
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
supplementscene: I call Lift, Catte and Booktooth as my provisional all 3 scum players
avatar
Telika: So how do you interpret Atlo's warning about Catte (post 457) ?
I asked him about that within a short time after he made the comment. He never elaborated. Either:

1. He sees Catte stating the Mason should declare as a sign that Catte is Town
2. He has a PR that means he knows Catte is likely town
3. Atlo's Scum and he's buddying Town Catte
4. They're a Scum team together

I don't see any alternatives unless I've missed something. Either way Atlo isn't getting lynched today
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
my name is anime catte: It sounds to me that you're accusing Liftraisal of lying but voting for the person you're accusing him of lying about.
avatar
supplementscene: Lift's wagon isn't going anywhere, isn't viable and we're less than 2 hours to lynch. Plus you voted for me. If you want to switch your vote to Lift, I'll move mine back. Otherwise it's on your wagon
No, I'm not voting for Lift today.
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
Lifthrasil: @Scene: sure. A protective role who announces whom they are going to protect. If you really are what you say you are that would be a bad idea, even by your standard.
It's a good tactic actually because Scum probably won't target them. And we preverve PRs
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
Telika: So how do you interpret Atlo's warning about Catte (post 457) ?
avatar
supplementscene: I asked him about that within a short time after he made the comment. He never elaborated. Either:

1. He sees Catte stating the Mason should declare as a sign that Catte is Town
2. He has a PR that means he knows Catte is likely town
3. Atlo's Scum and he's buddying Town Catte
4. They're a Scum team together

I don't see any alternatives unless I've missed something. Either way Atlo isn't getting lynched today
Do you really believe that something like point .1 (that is, standard guesswork) would lead to such a statement and mystery wrapping ("in due time", etc) ?

How are point 2., 3. and 4. even compatible with your scumlist (Lift, Catte, Buck) ?
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
supplementscene: I asked him about that within a short time after he made the comment. He never elaborated. Either:

1. He sees Catte stating the Mason should declare as a sign that Catte is Town
2. He has a PR that means he knows Catte is likely town
3. Atlo's Scum and he's buddying Town Catte
4. They're a Scum team together

I don't see any alternatives unless I've missed something. Either way Atlo isn't getting lynched today
avatar
Telika: Do you really believe that something like point .1 (that is, standard guesswork) would lead to such a statement and mystery wrapping ("in due time", etc) ?

How are point 2., 3. and 4. even compatible with your scumlist (Lift, Catte, Buck) ?
Because my Scumlist may be wrong. I tend to think Atlo's Town. BUT he might not be. I can't really hang on his presumption that Catte is 'innocent' with no insight of why. Do you suggest I vote for myself instead?

The other possibility is Catte and Atto are Masons ofcourse
Posted November 06, 2022
This is going really fast...

avatar
Telika: Uh? Yes, seriously, why ?

There are town trackers and there a mafia trackers.
I did not know that.

avatar
JoeSapphire: it's maybe best i don't say to keep info from the mafias, though if people would prefer it i will
Telika said she prefers not to.
avatar
Telika: Not certain I should allow Joe to answer that. On one hand it would be a nice verification system, on the other hand it would only verify if Joe is a tracker, which is independent from alignment.
Current standings, If I count correctly...

JoeSapphire - Telika, bucktooth #482 #492
supplementscene - Lift, Catt #505 #506
Catte - yogsloth, Scene #415 #509

Not voting: Atlo, CatVenturer, dedoporno, JoeSapphire

Time until deadline: 2h 50mins.

avatar
dedoporno: Countdown link.
Great link!
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
Catventurer: Day 2 now ends on 6th November, 6PM UTC+1 (London time)
avatar
Atlo: Time until deadline: 2h 50mins.

avatar
dedoporno: Countdown link.
avatar
Atlo: Great link!
One of these is wrong. Which one?
Posted November 06, 2022
avatar
Telika: Do you really believe that something like point .1 (that is, standard guesswork) would lead to such a statement and mystery wrapping ("in due time", etc) ?

How are point 2., 3. and 4. even compatible with your scumlist (Lift, Catte, Buck) ?
avatar
supplementscene: Because my Scumlist may be wrong.
I'm saying that, unless you firmly believe point 1 (that is that Atlo is a mislead honest townie with no solid reason to clear Catte), then you know that your scumlist is false. It's beyond "may be wrong".

So not sure if you simply didn't think it through, or if you're making it on the go and lose track of your rationalizations.

Anyway, just in case I'm not here in day 3, my main suspects are :

MAFIA Joe OR Scene
MAFIA Buck
MAFIA Dedop

Atlo/Catte unlikely (pending reveal of Atlo's justification, and credibility assessment of them)
Lifth unlikely (bad irrational vibes about him, but when looking for rational causes of concern, don't find anything notable)
All others, believed townies.
Posted November 06, 2022
Good morning! I'm awake, and we're 2 hours to nightfall.
I'm going to try to catch up quickly

vote Joe


I think our mafia team is Scene + Joe.
Pages:
1
10
20
30
33
34
35
36
37
50
58
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #78 - Regular Japanese Classroom(865 posts)(865 posts)
(865 posts)