Yes! Of course!

@lift - thanks for a great game. Cool flavor and I liked the phases.

@flubb - good call, well done

@muddy - great first game

@p1na - good job, you were so pure it was impossible not to believe you

@Ixam - you make me smile, way to go for it

@bler - I don't respect that play at all, but hey, you do you

@all - thanks for a great game

I'm done with mafia for a while, Happy Holidays all!

It wasn't until I did a thorough reread of you and bler144 last Night.

What I saw, with fresh eyes, was scummier bler144 rather than scummy muddysneakers.

I truly didn't know anything, just a hunch.

It was actually agentcarr wearing a Bernard Black mask that you were thinking of in that post, so you got 3/3.

What were your pointers in your reads?

Thanks a bunch for hosting, Lifthrasil, and to all for a good game.

The two phases and voting mechanics added a lot to the interesting setup. Not a fan of the double-lynch as it invited all sorts of manipulation, I think a random resolution of a tie would have worked better.

And I loved the flavour!

Probs to muddysneakers for a very good first game. [emphasis added]

I'm sure this means that the evil witch and me weren't related, phew!

I can't remember who or when, but someone suggested a double lynch mechanic that had you vote for a separate double lynch wagon, i.e. vote SPF+HSL. This wouldn't count as a vote on either individual wagon, thus it would prevent last second manipulation. Just as no lynch can have strategic uses, there are situations where a double lynch could be helpful.
But yes, as a way of resolving two separate wagons I agree that a double lynch is dangerous and easy to manipulate.

Yes, I agree.

BTW, is Ixam ok? Anyone have any contact with him since his last post in the game?

I had contact via chat once, after his death. Don't know where he disappeared to after that.

Similar question: has anyone seen Vitek? He disappeared a bit before the game started and I haven't gotten any reply from him since.

First off, gg Town! We almost got ya. XD

If I left my vote on flubbucket, I would have forced bler144 to either hammer me or help kill flubbucket. If he was going to hammer me, I might as well do it myself. If he helps kill flubbucket, that hurts him Day 5. So I thought that self-hammering gave him the best chances going into Day 5. I expected him to NK flubbucket, though, and hope that there was enough WIFOM he wouldn't die. We didn't have very good chances either way, though.

Funny thing that. I didn't know bler144 was scum until a couple of days into Day 1. Lifthrasil had forgotten to tell us who our partners were.

@Lifthrasil - thanks for the game! It was a fun first game back.

I'm not sure I agree with that. If he hammered you, it would have been functionally equivalent but it might have allowed him to look (a tiny bit) more town. I did enjoy the WTF factor of your self hammer though!

Yeah, thinking about it afterwards, we were really playing toward a draw at that point, which is a bad position. So I was also hoping I might cause a bit of confusion.

Now I think about it, lynching flub would have brought you to an interesting game state. He almost certainly would have taken you or bler with him, which would have resulted in a draw if you then did a night kill.

EDIT: Post was gibberish.

Mistakes were made.

But then again, I've never been particularly good at this game. XD